Starter & Flour

A simple rye loaf for every day

· 10 min read

This is the loaf I bake most often: dense, moist, with a light tang, it slices thin without crumbling and only tastes better on the third day. Here is my working recipe and all the caveats I have collected over years of baking it.

Proportions and why they are what they are

I count everything in percentages of the total flour weight, because that way the recipe scales to any loaf size. My base layout for one loaf: five hundred grams of flour in total, of which three hundred fifty grams are whole rye flour, that is seventy percent, and one hundred fifty grams are bread-grade wheat flour, thirty percent. Water is four hundred twenty grams, which is eighty-four percent hydration. Salt is ten grams, two percent. Ready starter, at its peak, is one hundred grams, twenty percent.

Why a blend and not pure rye? A purely rye loaf without wheat gluten comes out very dense and moist, almost like a cake, and it is hard to bake through to the end. Thirty percent wheat flour gives enough gluten for the crumb to hold its shape without turning the bread into a wheat loaf. If you like a really dense, almost custardy taste, try raising the rye to eighty percent, but be ready for a longer bake and a mandatory rest before slicing.

Eighty-four percent hydration sounds high, but rye flour drinks water far more eagerly than wheat, and the dough will actually be thick, like soft clay, not runny. Do not be frightened by the number and do not add flour by eye during mixing: extra flour is the most common cause of dry, crumbly rye bread. If the dough sticks to your hands, wet your hands with water instead of dusting more flour.

Mixing without a machine

First I mix the water and the starter in a large bowl and stir until even, then add the salt and stir again. Only then do I pour in both flours and mix with a spoon until no dry lumps remain. Rye dough is not kneaded the way wheat dough is: there is almost nothing to develop, the gluten is weak, and long kneading only warms it for no reason. Thorough mixing is enough — a minute or two, no more.

Then I let the dough rest for twenty minutes with the bowl covered by a plate. During that time the flour absorbs the water and the dough becomes noticeably firmer and more obedient. After that I do one or two folds with wet hands: lift an edge of the dough and fold it to the center, turn the bowl, repeat around the circle. For rye dough that is plenty; the ten-fold rituals from wheat blogs are not needed here and only take time.

If you have a bread machine or a stand mixer with a dough mode, you can hand it the mixing, but watch that the dough does not overheat: rye dough likes a temperature around twenty-six to twenty-eight degrees, and overheating above thirty makes it sticky and capricious. I once overheated a dough with hot tap water and got a loaf with a sticky crumb that I had to dry out in the oven. Now I always check the water temperature with a thermometer — it is the only piece of technique I have allowed myself.

Fermentation and shaping

The first fermentation takes me three to four hours at room temperature. The dough should grow by about half and become bubbly along the edges of the bowl. Rye dough does not double as dramatically as wheat, so I look not only at volume but at the surface: small bubbles and a slight tremble of the dough say it is time to shape. If you overdo it, the dough begins to collapse and the bread will be sour — better a little under than a little over.

I shape with wet hands on a wet counter: gather the dough into a ball, roll it in circles so the surface tightens, and place it into a loaf pan greased with oil and dusted with flour or bran. A pan for rye bread is not a luxury but a necessity: weak gluten cannot hold a free-form loaf, and without a pan it spreads into a flatbread. My pan is an ordinary rectangular one, for a loaf of about a kilogram.

After shaping comes the final proof: another hour to an hour and a half in warmth, until the dough rises almost to the rim of the pan. The same rule works here, better a little less: if the dough overproofs in the pan, it will sink in the oven and the crumb will be dense. I go by the finger poke: a lightly pressed finger leaves a dent that slowly springs back halfway — time to bake. If the dent vanishes instantly, the dough is not ready; if it does not spring back at all, you are late, bake immediately and shorten the proof next time.

Baking in an ordinary oven

I preheat the oven to two hundred forty degrees well ahead, at least half an hour, with an empty tray on the lower level. I put the pan on the middle level, pour a cup of boiling water into the hot tray, and close the door at once: steam in the first minutes keeps the crust from setting too early and lets the loaf finish rising. After fifteen minutes I vent the steam, drop the temperature to two hundred, and bake for another forty to fifty minutes.

I check doneness not by color but by sound and temperature: a loaf taken out of the pan and tapped on the bottom should sound hollow, and a thermometer stuck into the center of the crumb should read about ninety-six to ninety-eight degrees. Rye bread is easy to underbake, and an underbaked crumb will be sticky and seem raw even when the crust looks done. If in doubt, give it ten more minutes; for rye bread that almost never hurts.

After baking I take the loaf out of the pan immediately and lay it on a wire rack to cool. And here is the hardest rule of the whole recipe: rye bread must not be cut hot, and it must not be cut fully cooled on the same day either. It needs a rest of at least twelve hours, better a full day, wrapped in a towel or in a paper bag. During that time the crumb finishes setting, the moisture redistributes, and the bread stops sticking to the knife. I bake in the evening and slice the next morning — it is the one discipline I keep without exception.

If the crumb is sticky: a short diagnosis

A sticky crumb is the main complaint about rye bread, and it usually has three causes. First: underbaking — check the crumb temperature and add time. Second: dough too warm during fermentation — watch the water and kitchen temperature. Third: the loaf was cut too early — give it its rest. Less often the cause is the flour: sprouted grain gives flour with high enzyme activity, and such bread is always sticky — change the flour brand and compare the result.

I store the loaf cut-side down on a board, covered with a towel, for the first two days, then in a paper bag. In the fridge rye bread stales faster than at room temperature, so the fridge is not a place for bread unless you plan to freeze it. About freezing, and about fitting all this baking into a working week, I wrote separately — in the note on the baking schedule.